All the Light We Cannot See By Anthony Doerr
I’m not usually a fan of historical fiction, but I did really enjoy this book. It’s set before and during WWII. The story follows two main characters, Marie-Laure, the blind daughter of a museum worker in Paris, and Werner, an orphan living in a German mining town. Each character has two plot lines, one taking place before the war in 1934 and one taking place near the end of the war in 1945.
Marie-Laure’s 1934 plot line follows her as she navigates Paris as a newly-blind person. It details her learning how to read braille and find her way around the streets in her neighborhood. After Germany occupies Paris in 1940, Marie-Laure and her father are entrusted with a priceless gemstone from the natural history museum’s collection.
Werner’s 1934 plot line details his life in a poor German orphanage and how Hitler’s propaganda indoctrinates young children. After being noticed for his skills with radios, Werner is sent to a Hitler Youth academy where he is trained to join the German army.
These two plot lines happen simultaneously with their 1945 stories. In both, the characters are trapped in the same French town being bombed.
While I did enjoy this book, there are a few reasons I gave it 4 stars instead of 5. The chapters are extremely short (sometimes only a page or two), and it switches constantly between both characters and each of their plot lines. This makes the book harder to follow, as there are seemingly many events happening at the same time. It also prevented me from immersing myself in any one story, as they were constantly being interrupted. Overall, the story was strong and compelling, though the ending did make the story feel more cheap. Without going into spoilers, Werner lacked character development and his story at the end was noticeably weaker than Marie-Laure’s. Despite being indoctrinated as a child and a member of the German army, Werner never has to face the reality of his actions. He lacks emotional or ideological conflict, and seems to go through the story unaware of the Holocaust. I don’t doubt that many German soldiers were unaware of the extent of the tragedy, but the fact that Werner never addresses it makes it seem like he got the “easy way out.”
Overall, I thought this was a well written and thought-provoking story. The characters were likable despite their faults and hardships, though they lacked a level of ideological depth I wanted to see from this story. My main issue with Werner was that he lacked development or conflict, as if he remained the same character over the 11 years the book spans. Maire-Laure was a stronger character, however she spent most of the story in hiding. This led to her character lacking agency or drive for stretches of the story.
I would recommend this book to others. It’s a good jumping off point for people new to historical fiction and is a surprisingly quick read despite being over 500 pages.
-Alaina